|
The online versions of legislation provided on this website are NOT official. The official version of bills are available from the LSC Bill Room located at the north end of the Ground Floor of the Statehouse. Enrolled bills are the final version passed by the Ohio General Assembly and presented to the Governor for signature. The official version of acts signed by the Governor are available from the Secretary of State's Office in the Continental Plaza, 180 East Broad St., Columbus.
|
H. B. No. 75 As IntroducedAs Introduced
| 126th General Assembly | | Regular Session | | 2005-2006 |
| |
Representatives Harwood, Law, Carano, Kearns, S. Patton, Miller, Distel, Skindell
A BILL
To amend sections 3714.01, 3714.02, 3714.03, 3714.04,
3714.05,
3714.06, 3714.08, and 3714.09, to enact sections 3714.051, 3714.101, and 3714.30 to
3714.40, and to repeal section 3714.021 of the
Revised Code to revise the
siting criteria for a
construction and demolition
debris facility, to establish an application fee for an initial construction and demolition debris facility license, to require monthly inspections of construction and demolition debris facilities, to
require background checks for
the operation of such
a facility, to require
post-closure bonding for
certain construction and
demolition debris
facilities, and to make other changes in the Construction and Demolition Debris Law.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF OHIO:
Section 1. That sections 3714.01, 3714.02, 3714.03, 3714.04,
3714.05,
3714.06, 3714.08, and 3714.09 be amended and
sections
3714.051, 3714.101, 3714.30, 3714.31, 3714.32, 3714.33,
3714.34,
3714.35, 3714.36, 3714.37, 3714.38, 3714.39, and 3714.40
of the
Revised Code be enacted to read as follows:
Sec. 3714.01. As used in this chapter: (A) "Board of health" means the board of health of a city
or general health district or the authority having the duties of
a board of health in any city as authorized by section 3709.05 of
the Revised Code. (B) "Closure" means either the time at which a
construction and demolition debris facility will no longer accept
construction and demolition debris for disposal or the effective
date of an order revoking the license of the facility. "Closure"
includes measures performed to protect public health or safety,
to prevent air or water pollution, or to make the facility
suitable for other uses, if any, including, without limitation,
the establishment and maintenance of suitable cover of soil and
vegetation over areas where construction and demolition debris is
buried and the minimization of erosion, the infiltration of
surface water into such areas, the production of leachate, and
the accumulation and runoff of contaminated surface water. (C) "Construction and demolition debris" means those
materials resulting from the alteration, construction,
destruction, rehabilitation, or repair of any physical
structure that is built by humans, including, without limitation, houses,
buildings,
industrial or commercial facilities, or roadways. "Construction and demolition debris" includes particles and dust created during demolition activities. "Construction
and demolition debris" does not include materials identified or
listed as solid wastes or hazardous waste pursuant to Chapter
3734. of the Revised Code and rules adopted under it; materials
from mining operations, nontoxic fly ash, spent nontoxic foundry
sand, and slag; or reinforced or nonreinforced concrete, asphalt,
building or paving brick, or building or paving stone that is
stored for a period of less than two years for recycling into a
usable construction material. (D) "Disposal" means the discharge, deposit, injection,
dumping, spilling, leaking, emitting, or placing of any
construction and demolition debris into or on any land or ground
or surface water or into the air, except if the disposition or
placement constitutes storage. (E) "Facility" means any site, location, tract of land,
installation, or building used for the disposal of construction
and demolition debris. "Facility" does not include any
construction site where construction debris and trees and brush
removed in clearing the construction site are used as fill
material on the site where the materials are generated or removed
and does not include any site where materials composed
exclusively of reinforced or nonreinforced concrete, asphalt,
clay tile, building or paving brick, or building or paving stone
are used as fill material, either alone or in conjunction with
clean soil, sand, gravel, or other clean aggregates, in
legitimate fill operations for construction purposes or to bring
the site up to a consistent grade. (F) "Health district" means a city or general health
district created by or under the authority of Chapter 3709. of
the Revised Code. (G) "Person" includes the state, any political subdivision
of the state or other state or local body, the United States and
any agency or instrumentality thereof, and any legal entity or
organization defined as a person under section 1.59 of the
Revised Code. (H) "Storage" means the holding of construction and
demolition debris for a temporary period in such a manner that it
remains retrievable and substantially unchanged and, at the end
of the period, is disposed of or reused or recycled in a
beneficial manner.
Sec. 3714.02.
Within twelve months after
July 24, 1990, the
The
director of environmental protection
shall adopt, and may
amend and rescind, rules in accordance with
Chapter 119. of the
Revised Code governing construction and
demolition debris
facilities and the inspection of and issuance
of licenses for
those facilities. The rules shall ensure that
the facilities will
not create a nuisance, fire hazard, or health
hazard or cause or
contribute to air or water pollution. The
rules shall establish
all of the following: (A) Standards for the design and construction of
facilities.
These standards may include, without limitation,
requirements for
diking around the areas where debris is buried
to prevent runoff
of surface water onto adjacent property. (B) Standards for control over access to facilities; (C) Standards for the operation of facilities, including,
without limitation, standards for the compaction and covering of
debris disposed of and standards regarding equipment used for the
operation of facilities; (D) Criteria and procedures for granting authorization to
the owner or operator of a facility to dispose of asbestos or
asbestos-containing materials or products at
his
the owner's or
operator's facility; (E) Requirements for the installation of ground water
monitoring wells and the monitoring of ground water quality at
any
facility where the operation of the facility threatens to
contaminate ground water;. The rules shall require annual sampling and laboratory analysis of ground water and leachate samples and testing for the presence of organic compounds and heavy metals that the director determines to be necessary and any other factor that the director determines to be necessary. (F) Requirements respecting written, narrative plans for
the
operation of facilities; (G) Requirements respecting contingency plans for
effective
action in response to fire or explosion at a facility; (H) Financial assurance requirements for the closure
and
post-closure care
of
facilities. The rules shall require that the
owner or operator
of a facility, before being issued a license for
the facility
under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code, submit a
surety bond,
a letter of credit, or other acceptable financial
assurance, as specified by
the director in the rules, in an
amount
equal to the estimated costs for closure
and post-closure care
of
those portions
of the facility that have been, are being, or are
to be used for
the disposal of construction and demolition debris
as contained
in the closure plan for the facility approved by the
board of
health of the health district in which the facility is or
is to
be located or, if the facility is or is to be located in a
health
district that is not on the approved list under division
(A) or
(B)(1) or (2) of section 3714.09 of the Revised Code, by
the
director.
The rules establishing financial assurance
requirements for the post-closure care of facilities do not apply
for twenty-four months after the effective date of this amendment
to a facility for which a license was issued
on or before the
effective date of this amendment. (I) Requirements for the closure of facilities. The
requirements shall include minimum requirements for the closure
of
all facilities and such additional requirements as are
reasonably
related to the location of the facility and the type
and quantity
of materials disposed of in the facility.
(J) Requirements for the post-closure care of facilities that
are reasonably
related to the continued maintenance of ground
water monitoring
wells and to the monitoring of ground water at a
facility as
provided under section 3714.101 of the Revised Code. The rules adopted under this section shall not prohibit the
open burning of construction debris on a construction site in
compliance with division (C)(1) of section 3704.11 of the Revised
Code.
Sec. 3714.03. (A) As used in this section: (1) "Aquifer system" means one or more geologic units or
formations that are wholly or partly saturated with water and are
capable of storing, transmitting, or yielding ground water at a
time weighted average rate greater than one-tenth of a gallon per
minute over a twenty-four-hour period unless the geologic units or
formations yield less than three gallons per minute, but more than
one-tenth of a gallon per minute and the ground water yield is
less than fifty per cent of the yield of another saturated zone
under a construction and demolition debris facility that is the
likely source of water used for any purpose within one mile of the
facility. (2) "Category 3 wetland" means a category 3 wetland as
described in rule 3745-1-54 of the Administrative Code as that
rule existed on the effective date of this amendment. (3) "Community water system" has the same meaning as in
section 6109.01 of the Revised Code. (4) "Drinking water source protection area for a community
water system using ground water" means the surface and subsurface
areas surrounding a public water supply well that will provide
water from an aquifer to the well within five years as delineated
or endorsed by the environmental protection agency in accordance
with the wellhead protection program or the source water
assessment protection program established pursuant to section
6109.04 of the Revised Code.
(5)
"Limits of construction and demolition debris placement"
means the areal and vertical limits of debris placement within a
construction and demolition debris facility and includes the
volume of debris placement. (6)
"Natural area" means any of the following:
(a) An area designated by the director of natural resources
as a scenic river under section 1517.14 of the Revised Code; (b) An area designated by the United States department of the
interior as a national scenic river;
(c) An area designated by the United States forest service
as either a special interest area or a research natural area in
the Wayne national forest; (d) An area designated, owned, and managed by the Ohio
historical society as a nature preserve;
(e) A stream segment designated by the environmental
protection agency under Chapter 6111. of the Revised Code and
rules adopted under it as a state resource water, a coldwater
habitat, or an exceptional warmwater habitat.
(B)
Neither the director of environmental
protection nor any
board of health shall issue a license under
section 3714.06 of the
Revised Code to establish and operate a
new construction and
demolition debris facility when
any portion
the limits of
construction and demolition debris placement of the facility
is
are proposed to be located in
either
any
of the
following
locations: (A)(1)
Within the boundaries of
the
a one-hundred-year flood
plain
of a watercourse, as those boundaries are shown on the
applicable maps prepared under the "National Flood Insurance Act
of 1968," 82 Stat. 572, 42 U.S.C.A. 4001, as amended, unless the
owner or operator has obtained an exemption from
this division
(B)(1) of this section
in
accordance with section 3714.04 of the
Revised Code.
With
respect to watercourses or portions thereof
for
which
If no such
maps have been prepared, the boundaries of
the
a
one-hundred-year
flood plain shall be determined by the applicant
for a license
based upon
a design storm of seven inches of
precipitation in
twenty-four hours and upon standard methodologies
set forth in
"urban hydrology for small watersheds" (soil
conservation service
technical release number 55) and section 4 of
the "national
engineering hydrology handbook" of the soil
conservation service
of the United States department of
agriculture.
(B)(2) Within the boundaries of a sole source aquifer
designated by the administrator of the United States
environmental
protection agency under the "Safe Drinking Water
Act," 88 Stat.
1660 (1974), 42 U.S.C.A. 300f, as amended;
(3) Above an unconsolidated aquifer system that sustains a
one hundred gallon per
minute yield for a twenty-four-hour period
to an existing or future water supply well located within one
thousand feet of the limits of construction and demolition debris
placement of the facility. The existence of such an aquifer
system shall be determined through publicly available information
or hydrogeologic site investigation.
(C) Except as provided in division (I) of this section,
neither the director nor any board shall issue a license
under
section 3714.06 of the Revised Code to establish and operate
a new
construction and demolition debris facility or to modify an
existing facility when the limits of construction and demolition
debris placement at the new facility or at
any new
portion of the
existing facility are proposed to be
located in any
of the
following locations: (1) Within one thousand feet of a water supply
well; (2) Within two hundred feet of a stream, lake, or category 3
wetland; (3) Within two hundred feet of the facility's property
line; (4) Within one thousand feet of a state park established or
dedicated under Chapter 1541. of the Revised Code, a state park
purchase area established under section 1541.02 of the Revised
Code, any unit of the national park system, or any property that
lies within the boundaries of a national park or recreation area,
but that has not been acquired or is not administered by the
secretary of the United States department of the interior, located
in this state, or any area located in this state that is
recommended by the secretary for study for potential inclusion in
the national park system in accordance with "The Act of August 18,
1970," 84
Stat. 825, 16 U.S.C.A. 1a-5, as amended; (5) If a liner and a leachate management system are used at
the
facility, above the subsurface area of potential subsidence to
an
underground mine. (D) Except as provided in division (I) of this section,
neither the director nor any board shall issue a license
under
section 3714.06 of the Revised Code to establish and operate
a new
construction and demolition debris facility or to modify an
existing facility when the limits of construction and demolition
debris placement at the new facility or
at
any new
portion of an
existing facility are proposed to be
located
less
than five feet
above the uppermost aquifer system. (E) Except as provided in division (I) of this section,
neither the director nor any board shall issue a license
under
section 3714.06 of the Revised Code to establish and operate
a new
construction and demolition debris facility or to modify an
existing facility when the limits of construction and demolition
debris placement at the new facility or at
any new portion of an
existing facility are proposed to be located
in a drinking water
source protection area for a community water
system using ground
water. (F) Neither the director nor any board shall issue a license
under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code to establish and operate
a new construction and demolition debris facility when the limits
of construction and demolition debris placement
of the new
facility are proposed to be located within one thousand
feet of a
natural area, any area established by the department of
natural
resources as a state wildlife area under Chapter 1531. of
the
Revised Code and rules adopted under it, any area that is
formally
dedicated as a nature preserve under section 1517.05 of
the
Revised Code, or any area designated by the United States
department of the interior as a national wildlife refuge. (G) Neither the director nor any board shall issue a license under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code to establish and operate a new construction and demolition debris facility unless the areas at the new facility where construction and demolition debris will be placed will have a liner comprised of not less than eighteen inches of compacted clay and the new facility will install and operate a ground water monitoring system and leachate management system.
(H)
As used in this section, "new portion of an existing
facility" means any area of an existing facility that has not been
designated as an active or inactive licensed disposal area for the
facility.
(I)
Divisions (C), (D), and (E) of this section do not apply
for twenty-four months after the effective date of this amendment
to a facility for
which a license was issued on or before the
effective date of this
amendment.
Sec. 3714.04. The director of environmental protection or
the board of health having territorial jurisdiction may by order
exempt any person disposing of or proposing to dispose of
construction and demolition debris in such quantities or under
such circumstances that, in the determination of the director or
board of health, are unlikely to adversely affect the public
health or safety or the environment, or to create a fire hazard,
from any provision of this chapter or a rule adopted or order
issued under it, other than division (B)(2) of section 3714.03 or
division (E) of section 3714.13 of the Revised Code. Neither the
director nor any board of health shall grant an exemption under
this section from division
(A)
(B)(1)
of section 3714.03 of the
Revised
Code if the director or board finds from the license
application
that the establishment of a new construction or
demolition debris
facility in the one-hundred-year flood plain of
a watercourse
would result in an increase of more than one foot in
the
elevation of the flood stage of the watercourse upstream or
downstream from the proposed facility. The applicant for a
license shall determine the increase in the flood stage resulting
from the location of the proposed facility within the
one-hundred-year flood plain of a watercourse based upon
a design
storm of seven inches of precipitation in twenty-four hours and
upon
standard methodologies set forth in "urban hydrology for
small watersheds" (soil conservation service technical release
number 55) and section 4 of the "national engineering hydrology
handbook" of the soil conservation service of the United States
department of agriculture.
Sec. 3714.05. The board of health of each health district
maintaining a program on the approved list under division (A) or
(B)(1) or (2) of section 3714.09 of the Revised Code shall
provide
for the inspection
or
of, licensing of, and enforcement
of
standards governing construction and demolition debris
facilities
under this chapter and rules adopted under it. The
director of
environmental protection shall provide for the
inspection and
licensing of construction and demolition debris
facilities, and
enforcement of standards in health districts that
are not on the
approved list under those divisions and may
provide for the
inspection of the facilities and enforcement of
standards in
health districts that are on the approved list under
those
divisions. Sec. 3714.051. Each person proposing to open a new
construction and demolition debris facility, prior to the
submission of an application for an initial license, shall hold a
public meeting in the township or municipal corporation, whichever
is applicable, where the proposed facility is to be located. The
director of environmental protection or the director's designee or
the board of health of the health district in which the facility
is to be located or the board's designee may attend the public
meeting. At least thirty days prior to the public meeting, the
person proposing to open a facility shall provide notice of the
time, day, and location of the public meeting in a newspaper of
general circulation in the locality of the proposed facility and
mail a copy of the notice to the director or board of health,
whichever is applicable.
Sec. 3714.06. (A) No person shall establish, modify,
operate, or maintain a construction and demolition debris
facility
without a construction and demolition debris facility
installation
and operation license issued by the board of health
of the health
district in which the facility is or is to be
located or, if the
facility is or is to be located in a health
district that is not
on the approved list under division (A) or
(B)(1) or (2) of
section 3714.09 of the Revised Code, from the
director of
environmental protection. Each person proposing to
open a new
construction and demolition debris facility or to
modify an
existing facility shall, at least ninety days before
proposed
operation of the facility, submit an application for a
license
with accompanying plans, specifications, and information
regarding
the facility and its method of operation to the board
of health of
the health district in which the facility is located
or proposed
for approval as complying with the rules adopted
under section
3714.02 of the Revised Code and the standards set
forth in
divisions (A) and (B) of section 3714.03 of the Revised
Code or,
if the health district in which the facility is located
or
proposed to be located is not on the approved list under
division
(A) or (B)(1) or (2) of section 3714.09 of the Revised
Code, to
the director for approval as complying with those rules
and
standards. If the board of health or the director, as
appropriate, finds that the proposed facility or modification
complies with those rules and standards, the board or director
shall issue a license for the facility. Any such license may be
issued with such terms and conditions as the board or the
director, as appropriate, finds necessary to ensure that the
facility will comply with this chapter and the rules adopted
under
it and to protect the public health and safety and the
environment. Licenses issued under this section expire annually
on the thirty-first day of December.
An application for a license to open a new construction and demolition debris facility shall be accompanied by the fee established in section 3714.061 of the Revised Code. (B) During the month of December, but before the first day
of January of the next year, each person proposing to continue
with construction or operation of a construction and demolition
debris facility shall procure a license for the facility for that
year from the board of health of the health district in which the
facility is located or, if the facility is located in a health
district that is not on the approved list under division (A) or
(B)(1) or (2) of section 3714.09 of the Revised Code, from the
director. The application for a license shall be submitted to
the
board of health or the director, as appropriate, on or before
the
last day of September of the year preceding that for which
the
license is sought.
A person who has received a license, upon
sale
or disposition of the facility, may, with the consent of the
board
or the director, as appropriate, have the license
transferred to
another person. (C)
The owner or operator of a construction and demolition
debris facility that is in operation or under construction on the
effective date of this section shall, within six months after the
effective date of the rules adopted under section 3714.02 of the
Revised Code, submit to the board of the health district in which
the facility is located or under construction an application for
a
construction and demolition debris facility installation and
operation license and accompanying plans, specifications, and
information regarding the facility and its method of operation.
If
the health district in which such an existing facility is not
on
the approved list under division (A) or (B)(1) or (2) of
section
3714.09 of the Revised Code, the owner or operator of the
facility
shall submit the application for a license and
accompanying plans,
specifications, and information regarding the
facility and its
method of operation to the director within that
time. The board
or the director, as appropriate, shall issue a
license for such an
existing facility within ninety days after
receiving a complete
application therefor and accompanying plans,
specifications, and
information if the board or the director
finds that the facility
complies with the rules adopted under
section 3714.02 of the
Revised Code. When issuing a license
under this division for an
existing facility or a license to
expand any existing facility
that was initially licensed under
this division onto contiguous
land owned by the owner or operator
of the existing facility on
the date on which the application for
a license for the facility
was submitted under this division,
neither the board nor the
director shall consider whether the
existing facility complies
with the standards set forth in
divisions (A) and (B) of section
3714.03 of the Revised Code. If the board of health or the director denies an
application
submitted under this division, the board or the
director shall
include in the order denying the application the
requirements that
the owner or operator of the facility submit a
plan for closure of
the facility to the board or the director, as
appropriate, for
approval within six months after issuance of the
order; cease
accepting construction and demolition debris for
disposal; and
commence closure of the facility within one year
after issuance of
the order.
(D) Upon issuance of a license under this section,
the
a board of health shall mail a copy of the license to the director.
If a license authorizes construction of a new facility or
modification of an existing facility, the board shall also mail
with the license a copy of the approved plans, specifications,
and
information regarding the facility and its method of
operation.
Sec. 3714.061. The fee for an application for an initial construction and demolition debris facility installation and operation license issued under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code is five thousand dollars. The fee shall accompany the application for the initial license submitted under that section and is nonrefundable.
A board of health issuing licenses under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code shall pay the money from the fee into the special fund of the health district created in section 3714.07 of the Revised Code. If the director of environmental protection issues licenses under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code, the director shall transmit money from the fee to the treasurer of state to be credited to the construction and demolition debris facility oversight fund created in section 3714.07 of the Revised Code.
Sec. 3714.08. (A) At least annually once each month, the board of health
of a health district or the director of environmental protection
shall cause each construction and demolition debris facility for
which the board or the director, as appropriate, issued a license
under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code to be inspected and
shall cause a record to be made of each inspection. The board or
the director shall require each such facility to be in
substantial compliance with this chapter and rules adopted under
it. (B) Within thirty days after the issuance of a license,
the board of health shall certify to the director of
environmental protection that the construction and demolition
debris facility has been inspected and is in substantial
compliance with this chapter and rules adopted under it. Each
board of health shall provide the director with such other
information as he the director may require from time to time. (C) The board of health or its authorized representative
and the director or his the director's authorized
representative, upon proper
identification and upon stating the purpose and necessity of an
inspection, may enter at reasonable times upon any public or
private property, real or personal, to inspect or investigate,
obtain samples, and examine or copy records to determine
compliance with this chapter and rules adopted under it. The
board of health or its authorized representative or the director
or his the director's authorized representative may apply for,
and any judge of
a court of record may issue, an appropriate search warrant
necessary to achieve the purposes of this chapter and rules
adopted under it within the court's territorial jurisdiction. If
entry is refused or inspection or investigation is refused,
hindered, or thwarted, the board of health or the director may
suspend or revoke the construction and demolition debris
facility's license. (D) If the entry authorized by division (C) of this
section is refused or if the inspection or investigation so
authorized is refused, hindered, or thwarted by intimidation or
otherwise and if the director, the board of health, or authorized
representative of either applies for and obtains a search warrant
under division (C) of this section to conduct the inspection or
investigation, the owner or operator of the premises where entry
was refused or inspection or investigation was refused, hindered,
or thwarted is liable to the director or board of health for the
reasonable costs incurred by either for the regular salaries and
fringe benefit costs of personnel assigned to conduct the
inspection or investigation from the time the entry, inspection,
or investigation was refused, hindered, or thwarted until the
search warrant is executed; for the salary, fringe benefits, and
travel expenses of the attorney general, prosecuting attorney of
the county, or city director of law, or an authorized assistant,
incurred in obtaining the search warrant; and for expenses
necessarily incurred for the assistance of local law enforcement
officers in executing the search warrant. In the application for
a search warrant, the director or board of health may request and
the court, in its order granting the search warrant, may order
the owner or operator of the premises to reimburse the director
or board of health for such of those costs as the court finds
reasonable. From moneys recovered under this division, the
director shall reimburse the attorney general for the costs
incurred by him the attorney general or his the
attorney general's authorized assistant in connection with
proceedings for obtaining the search warrant, shall reimburse the
political subdivision in which the premises is located for the
assistance of its law enforcement officers in executing the
search warrant, and shall deposit the remainder to the credit of
the construction and demolition debris facility oversight fund
created in section 3714.07 of the Revised Code. From moneys
recovered under this division, the board of health shall
reimburse the prosecuting attorney of the county or the city
director of law for the costs incurred by him the prosecuting
attorney or the city director of law or his the authorized
assistant of the prosecuting attorney or the city director of law in
connection with proceedings for obtaining the search
warrant, shall reimburse the political subdivision in which the
premises is located for the assistance of its law enforcement
officers in executing the search warrant, and shall deposit the
remainder of any such moneys to the credit of the special fund of
the health district created in section 3714.07 of the Revised
Code.
Sec. 3714.09. (A) The director of environmental
protection shall place each health district that is on the
approved list under division (A) or (B) of section 3734.08 of the
Revised Code on the approved list for the purposes of issuing
licenses under section 3714.06 of the Revised Code. Any survey
or resurvey of any such health district conducted under section
3734.08 of the Revised Code shall also determine whether there is
substantial compliance with this chapter. If the director
removes any such health district from the approved list under
division (B) of that section, the director shall also remove
the health
district from the approved list under this division and shall
administer and enforce this chapter in the health district until
the health district is placed on the approved list under division
(B) of section 3734.08 of the Revised Code or division (B)(1) of
this section. (B)(1) Upon the request of the board of health of a health
district that is not on the approved list under division (A) or
(B) of section 3734.08 of the Revised Code, the director may
place the board on the approved list for the purpose of licensing
construction and demolition debris facilities under section
3714.06 of the Revised Code if the director determines that
the board is
both capable of and willing to enforce all of the applicable
requirements of this chapter and rules adopted under it. (2) The director shall annually survey each health
district on the approved list under division (B)(1) of this
section to determine whether there is substantial compliance with
this chapter and rules adopted under it. Upon determining that
there is substantial compliance, the director shall place the
health district on the approved list under that division. The
director shall make a resurvey when in the director's
opinion a resurvey is
necessary and shall remove from the approved list under division
(B)(1) of this section any health district not substantially
complying with this chapter and rules adopted under it. (3) If, after a survey or resurvey is made under division
(B)(2) of this section, the director determines that a health
district is not eligible to be placed on the approved list or to
continue on that list, the director shall certify that fact
to the board of
health of the health district and shall administer and enforce
this chapter and rules adopted under it in the health district
until such time as the health district is placed on the approved
list. (4) Whenever the director is required to administer and
enforce this chapter in any health district under division (A) or
(B)(3) of this section, the director is hereby vested with
all of the
authority and all the duties granted to or imposed upon a board
of health under this chapter and rules adopted under it within
the health district. All application fees required to be paid to a board of health by section 3714.061 of the Revised Code, all disposal fees required to be paid to a board of health by
section 3714.07 of the Revised Code, and all such previous fees
paid to the board, together with any money from construction and demolition debris facility license fees that were required to be paid to the board under section 3714.07 of the Revised Code as that section existed prior to the effective date of this amendment April 15, 2005, that have not been expended or encumbered shall
be paid to the director and deposited by the director to the
credit of the
construction and demolition debris facility oversight fund
created in section 3714.07 of the Revised Code. (C) Nothing in this chapter limits the authority of the
director to initiate and pursue any administrative remedy or to
request the attorney general, the prosecuting attorney of the
appropriate county, or the city director of law of the
appropriate city to initiate and pursue any appropriate judicial
remedy available under this chapter to enforce any provision of
this chapter and any rules or terms or conditions of any license
or order adopted or issued under this chapter with respect to any
construction and demolition debris facility regardless of whether
the facility is located in a health district that is on the
approved list under division (A) or (B)(1) or (2) of this
section.
Sec. 3714.101. If the owner or operator of a construction and
demolition debris facility has been issued a license and the
facility is required to install ground water monitoring wells and
monitor the quality of ground water under this chapter and rules
adopted under it, the owner or operator shall maintain the ground
water monitoring wells and monitor the quality of ground water for
ten years after the closure of the facility. In addition, the
owner or operator shall provide financial assurance for the
continued maintenance of ground water monitoring wells and for
monitoring the quality of ground water for ten years after the
closure of the facility in accordance with rules adopted under
this chapter. Sec. 3714.30. As used in sections 3714.30 to 3714.40 of the
Revised Code: (A) "Applicant" means any person who submits an application
for a license for a construction and demolition debris facility. (B) "Application" means the forms and documents submitted for
a license for a construction and demolition debris facility. (C) "Business concern" means any corporation, association,
partnership, sole proprietorship, or other entity organized for
profit. (D) "Debt liability" means bonds, debentures, notes,
mortgages, loans of any kind, secured or unsecured, and other debt
instruments. (E) "Disclosure statement" means a written statement
submitted to the attorney general that contains all of the
information required under section 3714.32 of the Revised Code. (F) "Employed in a supervisory capacity" means that an
individual has been delegated authority in the interest of the
individual's employer to exercise the individual's independent
judgment to perform or effectively recommend any one or more of
the following actions: hiring, firing, transferring, suspending,
laying off, recalling, promoting, discharging, assigning,
rewarding, disciplining, directing, or adjusting grievances of
employees whose duties include, but are not limited to, the
evaluation, identification, labeling, monitoring of the effect of,
or disposal of construction and demolition debris. (G) "Empowered to make discretionary decisions" means that an
individual has been delegated authority in the interest of the
individual's employer to exercise the individual's independent
judgment in the management and disposal of construction and
demolition debris. (H) "Equity" means any ownership interest in a business
concern. (I) "Government entity" means a state, any agency of a
state, any political subdivision of a state, the United States,
and any agency or instrumentality of it. (J) "Key employee" means an individual, other than a public
official or employee as defined in division (B) of section 102.01
of the Revised Code who is required to file a statement under
section 102.02 of the Revised Code, who is employed by an
applicant in a supervisory capacity or empowered to make
discretionary decisions with respect to the construction and
demolition debris operations of the business concern, but does not
include any employee who is exclusively engaged in the physical or
mechanical collection, transportation, or disposal of construction
and demolition debris. If the applicant has entered into a
contract with another person to operate the facility that is the
subject of the license application, "key employee" includes those
employees of the contractor who act in a supervisory capacity or
who are empowered to make discretionary decisions with respect to
the construction and demolition debris operations of the business
concern. An officer or director of a business concern that is
required to file a disclosure statement under section 3714.31 of
the Revised Code who meets the definition of "key employee" shall
be considered a key employee for the purposes of the filing and
disclosure requirements of sections 3714.30 to 3714.40 of the
Revised Code. (K) "License" means the annual license required by section
3714.06 of the Revised Code for a construction and demolition
debris facility. (L) "Licensee" means any person who has received a license
for a construction and demolition debris facility and who is
either the owner or operator of the facility. (M) "Operator" means the person who is responsible for the
direct control or overall operation of a facility. (N) "Owns or controls" means either of the following: (1) Holding at least five per cent of the equity of a
publicly traded corporation or twenty-five per cent of the equity
of any other business concern either directly or through a holding
company or subsidiary; (2) Possessing the ability to control the purchase or sale of
at least five per cent of the equity of a publicly traded
corporation or twenty-five per cent of the equity of any other
business concern either directly or through a holding company or
subsidiary. (O) "Partner" means a person who holds a position as, or
similar to, a general partner as defined in section 1782.01 of
the Revised Code or a limited partner as defined in that section
or a person who shares profits and liability and has management
powers of a partnership, as "partnership" is defined in section
1775.05 of the Revised Code. (P) "Publicly traded corporation" means a corporation in
which the shares are listed on a national securities exchange, the
shares are regularly quoted by one or more members of a national
or affiliated securities association, or the shares are held by
fifty or more shareholders. (Q) "Relative" means a mother, father, sister, brother, aunt,
uncle, spouse, child, adopted child, step-child, or grandparent or
the parent, brother, or sister of a spouse. (R) "Sole proprietorship" means a form of business, other
than a partnership or corporation, in which one person owns all of
the assets and is solely liable for all the debts of the business.
"Sole proprietor" includes any individual or entity that is an
applicant or prospective owner. Sec. 3714.31. (A) Not later than one hundred eighty days
prior to the submission of an application to the director of
environmental protection or a board of health for a license for a
construction and demolition debris facility, the applicant shall
submit a disclosure statement to the attorney general. Upon
receipt of the disclosure statement, the attorney general shall
prepare an investigative report and send the report to the
director. The director shall review the report and may review the
disclosure statement. The director or a board of health shall
either approve or deny the license in accordance with this chapter
and rules adopted under it. However, if the director determines
that the report contains information that if submitted with a
license application would require a denial of the license under
section 3714.37 of the Revised Code, the director shall deny the
license. If a board of health is reviewing the application for a
license and the director determines that the report contains
information that if submitted with a license application would
require a denial of the license under section 3714.37 of the
Revised Code, the director shall notify the board of health
reviewing the application, and the board shall deny the license.
A
board of health reviewing an application for a license shall not
deny the license because of information contained in an
investigative report unless the director notifies the board that
the board must deny the license. The director's notification to a
board of health is not a final action and is not appealable under
Chapter 3745. of the Revised Code. (B)(1) Not later than one hundred eighty days prior to the
change of ownership of a licensed construction and demolition
debris facility, the prospective owner shall submit a disclosure
statement to the attorney general and shall submit to a board of
health or the director, as appropriate, an application for a
license. Upon receipt of the disclosure
statement, the attorney
general shall prepare an investigative
report and send the report
to the director. The director shall
review the report and may
review the disclosure statement. The
director shall either
approve or deny the change in ownership in
accordance with this
chapter and rules adopted under it. However,
if the director
determines that the report contains information
that if submitted
with a license application would require a
denial of the license
under section 3714.37 of the Revised Code,
the director shall deny
the change in ownership. If the director approves the change in ownership, a board of
health or the director shall issue a license to the new owner or
operator in accordance with this chapter and rules adopted under
it. Upon the issuance of a license to the new owner or operator,
the license issued to the former owner or operator is invalid. (2) Not later than one hundred eighty days prior to the
change of ownership of a closed construction and demolition debris
facility and if a prospective owner intends to submit an
application for a license to operate the facility as a
construction and demolition debris facility, the prospective owner
shall submit a disclosure
statement to the attorney general.
Upon
receipt of the disclosure
statement, the attorney general
shall
prepare an investigative
report and send the report to the
director. The director shall
review the report and may review the
disclosure statement. The
director shall either approve or deny
the change in ownership in
accordance with this chapter and rules
adopted under it. However,
if the director determines that the
report contains information
that if submitted with a license
application would require a
denial of the license under section
3714.37 of the Revised Code,
the director shall deny the change in
ownership. (3) If the parties to a change in ownership of a construction
and demolition debris facility proceed with the change prior to
the director's approval or denial of the change in ownership, the
parties shall include in all contracts or other documents
concerning the change language expressly making the change in
ownership subject to the approval of the director and expressly
negating the change in ownership if the director denies the change
in ownership under division (B)(1) or (2) of this section. (4) As used in division (B) of this section, "change in
ownership" includes any change in names, other than those of
officers, directors, or key employees, that are
contained in the
disclosure statement. (C) On the anniversary date of the submission of the
initial
disclosure statement under division (A) or (B) of this section for
a specific facility to the attorney general, or on another date
assigned by the attorney
general, the person that was required to
file the disclosure
statement annually shall submit to the
attorney general all
information required to be included in a
disclosure statement that
has changed or been added in the
immediately preceding year. If
there have been no changes in or
additions to that information,
the person shall submit to the
attorney general an affidavit
stating that there have been no
changes or additions during that
time period. In addition to the annual submission of information, the
following information shall be submitted to the attorney general
within the periods specified: (1) Not later than ninety days after the addition of a new
officer, director, partner, or key employee, all the information
that is required to be included in the disclosure statement for an
officer, director, partner, or key employee; (2) Not later than ninety days after the addition of a new
business concern, all the information that is required to be
included in the disclosure statement for a business concern; (3) Not later than ninety days after the judgment entry of a
new criminal conviction, all the information that is required to
be included in the disclosure statement regarding a conviction. The failure to timely provide the information may constitute
the basis for the revocation or denial of a license issued under
this chapter and rules adopted under it. However, prior to the
revocation or denial of a license, the director shall notify the
applicant of the director's intention to do so and allow the
applicant to explain, not later than fourteen days after the date
of the notice, why the information was not
provided. The director
shall consider an explanation received
during that period before
determining whether to revoke or deny
the license. Nothing in this chapter affects the authority of the director
or the attorney general under sections 3714.31 to 3714.40 of the
Revised Code to request information from a person at any other
time. (D) Not later than one hundred eighty days after receipt of a
disclosure statement under this section, the attorney general
shall prepare an investigative report and send the report to the
director. However, the attorney general or the director may
extend the deadline for a reasonable period for good cause. In
preparing the investigative report, the attorney general may
request and receive criminal history information from the federal
bureau of investigation and any other law enforcement agency or
organization. The attorney general may provide confidentiality
regarding the information received from a law enforcement agency
that may be imposed by that law enforcement agency as a condition
for providing the information to the attorney general. (E) The attorney general shall develop and provide the forms
required under this section. Sec. 3714.32. A disclosure statement shall include all of
the following: (A) A general narrative that describes the operations of the
applicant in terms of tonnage or cubic yards of construction and
demolition debris received, number of facilities operated, and
any other aspect that the applicant determines will accurately
represent the operations of the applicant. The applicant may
supplement the general narrative with recent photographs,
statistics, reports, or other materials. (B) The full name, business address and telephone number,
home address and telephone number, date of birth, social security
number, driver's license number, and any other names or aliases of
the applicant or, if the applicant is a business concern, of all
officers, directors, partners, and key employees of it and of all
individuals or business concerns holding more than five per cent
of the equity in or debt liability of that business concern or, if
the business concern is a publicly traded corporation, all
individuals or business concerns holding more than five per cent
of the equity in or debt liability of that business concern,
except that when the debt liability is held by a chartered lending
institution, the applicant need supply only the name and business
address of the lending institution; (C) The full name, business address and telephone number, and
federal tax identification number of any business concern in which
the applicant holds more than five per cent of the equity interest
and that disposes of construction and demolition debris; (D) A diagram showing the organization of the applicant's
business concerns; (E) A list of all officers, directors, partners, and key
employees of the applicant, as applicable, containing a summary of
their credentials and their responsibilities relevant to the
applicant and the applicant's facilities; (F) A description of the experience and credentials possessed
by the applicant, including any past or present licenses for the
disposal of construction and demolition debris, or, if the
applicant is a business concern, by the officers, directors,
partners, and key employees of it; (G) For the applicant and each business concern that is
required to be listed in the disclosure statement, a summary of
the history of environmental compliance for five years prior to
the date of submission of the disclosure statement for each
facility owned or operated by the applicant and each listed
business concern. If the applicant or a business concern listed
in the disclosure statement owns or operates one or more
construction and demolition debris facilities in this state, the
applicant or the business concern listed in the disclosure
statement shall submit the environmental compliance history only
for each facility located in this state. However, if an applicant
or a business concern listed in the disclosure statement does not own or operate
or has not previously owned or operated a construction and
demolition debris facility in this state, but has owned or
operated a construction and demolition debris facility in another
state, the applicant or the business concern listed in the
disclosure statement shall submit an environmental compliance
history for each facility located in another state. The
environmental compliance summary shall include all of the
following for each facility: (1) The name and address of the facility; (2) A list of all notices of violation issued for the
facility during the five years prior to the date of submission of
the disclosure statement; (3) A listing and explanation of any pending or final civil
prosecutions or administrative enforcement actions by government
agencies for the enforcement of environmental laws or rules
adopted under those laws against the applicant or a business
concern listed in the disclosure statement that result in a
finding or a settlement of a violation of any law or rule related
to the disposal of construction and demolition debris or of any
other environmental law or rule adopted under such a law that
results in the imposition of sanctions or in revocations or
denials of licenses issued by any state or federal authority
during the five years prior to the submission of the disclosure
statement. At a minimum, the listing shall include all of the
following for each action: (a) The docket number or other means of identifying the
action; (b) The agency or tribunal that issued the action; (c) The current status of the action; (d) The commencement date of the action; (e) A description of the alleged violation that includes the
location and date of the alleged violation; (f) For a resolved action, a summary of any sanctions, fines,
penalties, payment that is made or work or service that is
performed in lieu of a fine or penalty, corrective measures,
cessation or suspension of operations of a facility, revocation of
licenses or permits, or similar actions; (g) Any explanation of the action or alleged violation that
the applicant may submit. (H) A listing and explanation of any criminal prosecutions
pending against the applicant or any individuals or business
concerns that are required to be listed in the disclosure
statement. The listing shall include at a minimum all of the
following: (1) The number of the indictment, information, or complaint; (2) The date of the indictment, information, or complaint; (3) A description of the crimes allegedly committed; (4) The name and location of the court in which the
prosecution is occurring; (5) The current status of the prosecution; (6) Any explanation of the prosecution or alleged violations
that the applicant, individuals, or business concerns may submit. (I) A listing and explanation of any criminal convictions
against the applicant and any individuals or business concerns
required to be listed in the disclosure statement. The listing
shall include at a minimum all of the following: (1) The number of the indictment, information, or complaint; (2) The date of the indictment, information, or complaint; (3) A description of the crimes of which the applicant,
individual, or business concern was convicted; (4) The name and location of the court in which the
prosecution occurred; (5) A summary of any sentence or fine imposed; (6) Any explanation of the prosecution that the applicant,
individuals, or business concerns may submit. (J) Any written evidence or arguments submitted under
division (B) of section 3714.37 of the Revised Code that
demonstrates rehabilitation with regard to a conviction of a crime
specified in division (B) of section 3734.44 of the Revised Code; (K) A description of any program that the applicant has
instituted at a facility to ensure compliance with the
environmental laws of this state or any other state. Sec. 3714.33. (A) For purposes of section 3714.31 of the
Revised Code, an applicant shall provide any assistance or
information that is requested by the director of environmental
protection or the attorney general and shall cooperate in any
inquiry or investigation conducted by the director or the attorney
general and any hearing conducted by the director. If the
director or attorney general issues a formal request to answer any
inquiry or produce information, evidence, or testimony and an
applicant, officer, director, or partner of a business concern or
a key employee of the applicant refuses to comply with the
request, the director or a board of health may deny or revoke the
license of the applicant. (B) An applicant or prospective owner
who is required to
submit a disclosure statement under section
3714.31 of the Revised
Code for more than one facility located in
this state may submit
all required disclosure statements at one
time. If the applicant
or
prospective owner is required to submit a disclosure statement
for
two or more facilities, only one disclosure statement need be
submitted when the disclosure statement describes the relationship
of the individual or business concern to each of the facilities.
Submission of a disclosure statement under this division does not
eliminate the requirement under section 3714.34 of the Revised
Code to pay a disclosure statement fee or maintenance fee for each
facility. (C) An applicant or
prospective owner may submit a written
guidance request to the
attorney general for an informal,
nonbinding explanation of a
requirement regarding the disclosure
statement that is required to
be submitted under section 3714.31
of the Revised Code. Upon the
receipt of a written guidance
request, the attorney general may
provide assistance to the
applicant or prospective owner concerning the request.
Assistance
provided by the attorney general concerning a written
guidance
request under this division is not binding on any person
or
entity, including, but not limited to, an applicant, a prospective
owner, the attorney
general, the director of environmental
protection, or a local
board of health. The submission of a
written guidance request
under this division does not alter any
obligation or requirement
of this chapter. (D)(1) When a person who is submitting information in a
disclosure statement believes that certain information contained
in the statement is confidential and excepted from disclosure
under section 149.43 of the Revised Code, the person shall send to
the attorney general a written document that contains all of the
following: (a) An identification of the specific information in the
disclosure statement that the person who is submitting the
information believes is confidential; (b) A request that the identified specific information be
treated as confidential and excluded from disclosure; (c) An explanation that includes citations to specific
statutes, rules, or cases or to similar authority in order to
support the request of confidentiality of the identified specific
information; (d) An amount of evidence necessary to support the request to
exclude the identified specific information from disclosure as
determined by the attorney general. (2) The attorney general shall keep confidential any
identified specific information submitted under division (D)(1) of
this section for a minimum of seven days after the date on which
the attorney general determines that the information is not within
the exception to disclosure under section 149.43 of the Revised
Code. (E) For purposes of sections 3714.31 and 3714.32 of the
Revised Code, all of the following apply: (1) The individuals who prepared information or directed that
information be provided on behalf of a business concern regarding
a disclosure statement shall swear or affirm to the truth and
accuracy of the information. (2) Any information provided in a disclosure statement may be
supplemented with a written explanation. (3) The attorney general shall comply with section 7(b) of
the "Privacy Act of 1974," 88 Stat. 1897, 5 U.S.C. 552(a), as
amended, concerning the disclosure of social security numbers. (F) Nothing in sections 3714.31 and 3714.32 of the Revised
Code shall be construed to restrict or limit the scope of
information that the attorney general may seek pursuant to the
procedures established under sections 3714.31 to 3714.40 of the
Revised Code. Sec. 3714.34. (A) The attorney general may charge fees that
are necessary to pay the costs of administering and enforcing
sections 3714.31 to 3714.40 of the Revised Code. The attorney
general shall transmit the money collected under this section to
the treasurer of state who shall credit the money to the
construction and demolition debris background investigation fund,
which is hereby created in the state treasury. Money in the fund
shall be used solely to pay the attorney general's costs of
administering and enforcing sections 3714.31 to 3714.40 of the
Revised Code. (B) An applicant or
prospective owner of a construction and
demolition debris facility
shall pay an initial disclosure
statement fee established by the
attorney general. (C) An applicant or
prospective owner of a construction and
demolition debris facility
shall pay an annual update disclosure
statement fee established by
the attorney general. (D) An applicant or
prospective owner of a construction and
demolition debris facility
who is required to pay a fee under
division (B) or (C) of this
section shall pay the fee to the
attorney general not later than
the date on which the disclosure
statement is due. The payment of
the fee shall be in a form that
is acceptable to the attorney
general. (E) The attorney general shall adopt rules in accordance
with Chapter 119. of the Revised Code establishing the amount of
the fees required under this section. Sec. 3714.35. (A) An individual who is required to be listed
in a disclosure statement shall be fingerprinted in accordance
with the procedures established by the attorney general for
identification and investigation purposes. (B) Fingerprints shall be submitted only on a form prescribed
by the attorney general or on any fingerprint form that is
acceptable to the federal bureau of investigation. (C) Complete fingerprint forms shall be submitted with the
disclosure statement to the attorney general. (D) An applicant or
prospective owner shall arrange for
fingerprints to be taken of
all individuals who are required to be
fingerprinted under this
section. Fingerprints shall be taken and
certified by an employee
of a government entity that is approved
by the attorney general to
take fingerprints. Sec. 3714.36. (A) As used in this section: (1) "Documentary material" means the original or a copy of a
writing, drawing, graph, chart, photograph, phonorecord, or other
data compilation from which intelligence, relevant to any
investigation conducted to determine if a person is or has been
engaged in a violation of this chapter or rules adopted under it,
may be perceived with or without the use of detection devices. (2) "Investigative demand" means the written request of the
attorney general to require an individual or business concern to
produce documentary material for inspection, copying, or
reproduction, to answer written interrogatories under oath, to
appear before the attorney general and testify under oath, or to
do a combination of any of those demands. (B) When the attorney general has reasonable cause to believe
that an individual or business concern may be in possession,
custody, or control of any documentary material or may have
knowledge of any fact that is relevant to an investigation of an
applicant under sections 3714.31 to 3714.40 of the Revised Code,
the attorney general may issue in writing or cause to be served an
investigative demand upon the individual or business concern or
the representative or agent of the individual or business concern. (C) An investigative demand shall contain all of the
following: (1) A description of the conduct that is under investigation
and a statement of the provisions of law that are applicable to
the investigation; (2) If the investigative demand is for the production of
documentary material, all of the following: (a) A description of reasonable particularity of the
documentary material to be produced; (b) A date on which the documentary material shall be
assembled and made available for inspection, copying, or
reproduction; (c) An identification of the representative of the attorney
general to whom the documentary material shall be made available; (d) An identification of the location at which the material
is to be produced. (3) If the investigative demand is for answers to written
interrogatories, both of the following: (a) An identification of the representative of the attorney
general to whom the answers shall be delivered; (b) A date on which the answers shall be delivered to the
representative of the attorney general. (4) If the investigative demand is for oral testimony, both
of the following: (a) A date, time, and location for the oral testimony; (b) An identification of the representative of the attorney general
who will conduct the oral examination. (D) An investigative demand shall not contain any requirement
that would be unreasonable if that requirement was contained in a
subpoena or subpoena duces tecum issued by a court in the aid of a
grand jury investigation. In addition, except as provided in
division (G) of this section, an investigative demand shall not
require answers to any written interrogatories, the giving of oral
testimony, or the production of any documentary material that
would be privileged from disclosure if demanded by a subpoena or
subpoena duces tecum issued by a court in the aid of a grand jury
investigation. (E) Service of an investigative demand may be made and is
complete by either of the following: (1) Sending the investigative demand by certified mail to the
individual or business concern or to the individual's residence or
to the business concern's principal office or principal place of
business; (2) Delivering the investigative demand to the individual or
business concern or to a representative or agent of the individual
or business concern. (F) Not later than twenty days after receipt of an
investigative demand or at any time before the compliance date
specified in the demand, whichever is earlier, the individual or
business concern may file in the court of common pleas of the
county in which the individual resides or in which the individual
or business concern conducts business and serve the attorney
general a request for an order of the court to modify or set aside
the demand. However, if the individual or business concern
conducts business in more than one county, the request shall be
filed either in the county in which the individual or business
concern maintains the principal place of business or in the county
that may be agreed on between the individual or business concern
and the attorney general. (G)(1) When an individual who is served with an investigative
demand refuses to produce documentary material, to provide oral
testimony, or to answer written interrogatories on the basis of
the individual's privilege against self-incrimination, the
attorney general may file a written request with a court of common
pleas to compel compliance with the investigative demand. Unless
the court finds that to compel compliance with the investigative
demand would not further the administration of justice, the court
shall compel the individual to comply with the investigative
demand when all of the following apply: (a) The attorney general makes a written request to the court
of common pleas to compel compliance with the investigative demand
in spite of a claim of privilege. (b) The written request to compel compliance is filed with
the court of common pleas of the county in which the individual is
found or where the individual conducts business, except that if
the individual conducts business in more than one county, the
request is filed in the county in which the individual maintains a
principal place of business. (c) The court of common pleas informs the individual that by
complying with the investigative demand the individual will
receive immunity under division (G)(2) of this section. (2) If, but for division (G)(1) of this section, the
individual would have been privileged to withhold any documentary
material, answers to interrogatories, or oral testimony and the
individual complies with a court order under division (G)(1) of
this section compelling the individual to provide documentary
material, answer interrogatories, or provide testimony, the
documentary material, answers to interrogatories, or oral
testimony or any evidence derived from them shall not be used
against the individual in the prosecution of a crime or offense
concerning the documentary material, answers to interrogatories,
or oral testimony provided when the documentary material, answers
to interrogatories, or oral testimony is responsive to the
questions propounded. However, an individual who is granted
immunity under this division may be subject to criminal
prosecution for a violation of section 2921.11, 2921.12, or
2921.13 of the Revised Code or for contempt committed in providing
documentary material, answers to interrogatories, or oral
testimony when complying with the court order under division
(G)(1) of this section. (H) The attorney general is responsible for the custody, use,
and preservation of the documentary material that is obtained
pursuant to an investigative demand and for the return of the
documentary material as provided under this section. The attorney
general shall compile all documentary material, answers to
interrogatories, and transcripts of oral testimony that are
obtained pursuant to an investigative demand in a reasonable
manner. The documentary material, answers to interrogatories, and
transcripts of oral testimony are confidential and not subject to
disclosure. Unless otherwise ordered by a court of common pleas,
the documentary material, answers to interrogatories, and
transcripts of oral testimony shall not be available for
examination or copying by an individual other than an authorized
representative of the attorney general without the written consent
of the individual or business concern that provided them.
However,
the documentary material, answers to interrogatories, and
transcripts of oral testimony may be used in a grand jury
investigation, a case, or another official proceeding that
involves the issuance of a license under this chapter or that
involves an alleged violation of this chapter or rules adopted
under it. Materials and information compiled under this section
are discoverable only to the extent authorized by the rules of the
administrative or judicial tribunal in which a proceeding under
this chapter is proceeding. (I) Not later than twenty-four months after the date on which
the documentary material was made available to the attorney
general pursuant to an investigative demand or when copies of
documentary material obtained pursuant to an investigative demand
are no longer required for the investigation or pending proceeding
for which it was obtained, all copies of documentary material
shall be returned to the individual or business concern that
provided it unless a request to extend the twenty-four-month
period has been filed in the court of common pleas in which a
request for an order compelling compliance under division (G) of
this section may be filed. This division does not apply to
documentary materials that are under the control of a court or
grand jury. (J) A public employee shall provide to the attorney general
all information and assistance that are requested by the attorney
general when the information and assistance are within the
employee's possession or power. The attorney general shall
provide the same degree of confidentiality for any information
obtained under this division as the public employee from whom the
information was received is required to provide by law with
respect to the information. (K) No individual or business concern with the intent to
avoid, evade, prevent, or obstruct compliance in whole or in part
with an investigative demand made under this section shall remove,
conceal, withhold, destroy, mutilate, alter, or by any other means
falsify any documentary material that is the subject of an
investigative demand served on an individual or business concern.
If a court finds that an individual or business concern does not
comply with an investigative demand and the noncompliance was in
bad faith or for the purpose of delay, the court may order the
individual or business concern to pay to the attorney general the
reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees, incurred in
defending the investigative demand. In addition, the court may
invoke the sanctions provided by Civil Rule 37. (L) Nothing in this section prohibits the attorney general
from filing a complaint that alleges a violation of this chapter
or rules adopted under it that is not described in an
investigative demand or from using any of the evidence obtained
under this section or otherwise for purposes of the complaint. In
addition, nothing in this section prohibits the attorney general
from doing any of the following: (1) Presenting evidence obtained under this section or
otherwise to a grand jury impaneled for purposes of an alleged
violation of this chapter or rules adopted under it; (2) Requesting a court to compel the production of evidence
to present to a grand jury impaneled for purposes of an alleged
violation of this chapter or rules adopted under it; (3) Initiating a proceeding for the enforcement of a court
order to compel the production of evidence for purposes of an
alleged violation of this chapter or rules adopted under it; (4) Punishing a person for failure to comply with a court
order to compel the production of evidence for purposes of an
alleged violation of this chapter or rules adopted under it. (M) Except as provided in this section, no employee of the
office of the attorney general purposefully shall make available
documentary material, answers to interrogatories, or transcripts
of oral testimony that are obtained under an investigative demand
for copying or examination. (N) The court of common pleas in which the attorney general
files a request to enforce an investigative demand under this
section has jurisdiction to hear the matter presented. If the
attorney general demonstrates to the court in a proceeding
initiated under this section that the information sought is
relevant to an investigation authorized under this section, the
court shall order the individual or business concern to provide
the information requested by the attorney general. (O) If an individual or business concern neither resides nor
transacts business in this state, a judicial proceeding to
challenge or enforce an investigative demand under this section
shall be initiated in the court of common pleas of Franklin
county. Sec. 3714.37. (A) Except as provided in division (B) of this
section, no license shall be issued or renewed under this chapter
by the director of environmental protection or a board of health: (1) Unless the director or a board finds that the applicant,
in a prior performance record for the disposal of construction and
demolition debris, has exhibited sufficient reliability,
expertise, and competency to operate the construction and
demolition debris facility given the potential for harm to human
health and the environment that could result from the
irresponsible operation of the facility or, if no prior record
exists, that the applicant is likely to exhibit that reliability,
expertise, and competence; (2) Except as provided in division (B) of this section, if an
individual or business concern that is required to be listed in
the disclosure statement or is shown to have a beneficial interest
in the business of the applicant, other than an equity interest or
debt liability, by the investigation of the business of the
applicant has been convicted of a crime specified in division (B)
of section 3734.44 of the Revised Code or a violation of an
equivalent law of another jurisdiction; (3) Unless the director or a board of health finds that the
applicant has a history of compliance with environmental laws in
this state and other jurisdictions and is currently in substantial
compliance with, or on a legally enforceable schedule that will
result in compliance with, environmental laws in this state and
other jurisdictions; (4) With respect to the approval of a license, if the
director determines that current prosecutions or pending charges
in any jurisdiction for a crime specified in division (B) of
section 3734.44 of the Revised Code against an individual or
business concern required to be listed in the disclosure statement
or shown by the investigation to have a beneficial interest in the
business of the applicant, other than an equity interest or debt
liability, are of such magnitude that they prevent the finding
required under division (A)(1) of this section, provided that at
the request of the applicant or the individual or business concern
charged, the director or the board shall defer decision on the
application during the pendency of the charge. (B) No applicant shall be denied issuance or renewal of a
license on the basis of conviction of an individual or business
concern that is required to be listed in the disclosure statement
or shown to have a beneficial interest in the business of the
applicant, other than an equity interest or debt liability, by the
investigation of the business of the applicant for a crime
specified in division (B) of section 3734.44 of the Revised Code
if that applicant has affirmatively demonstrated rehabilitation of
the individual or business concern by a preponderance of the
evidence. If the individual was convicted of an offense that is a
felony, a license shall be denied unless five years have elapsed
since the individual was fully discharged from imprisonment and
parole for the offense or from a post-release control sanction
imposed under section 2967.28 of the Revised Code for the offense.
In determining whether an applicant has affirmatively demonstrated
rehabilitation, the director or a board of health shall request a
recommendation on the matter from the attorney general and shall
consider and base the determination on the following factors: (1) The nature and responsibilities of the position that a
convicted individual would hold; (2) The nature and seriousness of the offense; (3) The circumstances under which the offense occurred; (4) The date of the offense; (5) The age of the individual when the offense was committed; (6) If the offense was an isolated or repeated incident; (7) Any social conditions that may have contributed to the
offense; (8) Any evidence of rehabilitation, including good conduct in
prison or in the community, counseling or psychiatric treatment
received, acquisition of additional academic or vocational
schooling, successful participation in correctional work release
programs, or the recommendation of persons who have or have had
the applicant under their supervision. Additionally, if an applicant is a business concern,
rehabilitation shall be established when the applicant has
implemented formal management controls to minimize and prevent the
occurrence of violations and activities that will or may result in
license denial or revocation or when the applicant has formalized
those controls as a result of denial or revocation of a license.
Those controls may include, but are not limited to, instituting
environmental auditing programs to help ensure the adequacy of
internal systems to achieve, maintain, and monitor compliance with
applicable environmental laws and standards or instituting an
antitrust compliance auditing program to help ensure full
compliance with applicable antitrust laws. The business concern
shall prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the management
controls are effective in preventing the violations that are the
subject of concern. Sec. 3714.38. In addition to other causes for revocation of a
license under this chapter, the director of environmental
protection or a board of health may revoke a license for any of
the following causes: (A) Any cause that would require disqualification under
division (A)(1), (2), (3), or (4) of section 3714.37 of the
Revised Code from receiving a license upon original application; (B) Fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation in obtaining the
license or in the conduct of the licensed activity; (C) Offering, conferring, or agreeing to confer any benefit
to induce another individual or business concern to violate this
chapter, any rule adopted under it, or any other law relating to
the disposal of construction and demolition debris; (D) Coercion of a customer by violence or economic reprisal
or the threat of coercion by violence or economic reprisal to
utilize the services of the licensee; (E) Preventing, without authorization of the director or a
board of health, an individual or business concern from disposing
of construction and demolition debris at a licensed facility other
than a facility that is owned or operated by the applicant. Sec. 3714.39. Notwithstanding the disqualification of an
applicant pursuant to this chapter, the director of environmental
protection or a board of health may issue or renew a license if
the applicant severs the interest of or affiliation with the
individual or business concern that would otherwise cause that
disqualification or may issue or renew a license on a temporary
basis for a period not to exceed six months if the director or the
board of health determines that the issuance or renewal of the
license is necessitated by the public interest. Sec. 3714.40. (A) The attorney general may waive any of the
requirements established in sections 3714.31 to 3714.40 of the
Revised Code that are conditions for the issuance, renewal, or
revocation of a license when the applicant demonstrates, to the
satisfaction of the attorney general, both of the following: (1) Compliance with a requirement will create a substantial
hardship. (2) Compliance with a requirement will not likely elicit
information that is responsive to the requirement. If the attorney general waives a requirement under division
(A) of this section, the attorney general shall send to the
director of environmental protection or a board of health,
whichever is applicable, a written notification that describes
every requirement that is waived and that includes the name and
address of the applicant. (B) The attorney general may waive in whole or in part a fee
established under section 3714.34 of the Revised Code when the
applicant demonstrates that the payment of the fee either would
create a substantial hardship to the applicant or would create an
unjustifiable burden on the applicant.
Section 2. That existing sections 3714.01, 3714.02, 3714.03,
3714.04,
3714.05, 3714.06, 3714.08, and 3714.09 and section 3714.021 of the Revised
Code are
hereby repealed.
|
|